Is Trapped in the Closet the 21st Century's answer to Endurance Art?
Written by Rye Purvis


In Mitchell's Death, artist Linda Montano gives a raw 22 minute performance in which she recalls the events surrounding the death of her ex-husband Mitchell Payne in 1977. The lengthy video features nothing but a close-up direct portrait of Montano with acupuncture needles placed on various parts of her face. Throughout the entire twenty-two minute performance, Montano describes the details of Mitchell's death in a song-like fashion, repeating a defined rhythm--a chorus of sorts, but never raising her voice above the continuous neutral tone. Twenty-eight years later, mainstream R&B artist Robert Sylvester Kelly, more popularly known as "R. Kelly," releases the megahit Trapped in the Closet, a 22 chapter song/video featuring a soap opera type of story sung from the perspective of R. Kelly as the main character. As each chapter plays one after another, each four-minute chapter repeats the same rhythm, yet the plot continues forward. The gap between feminist performance high art and kitschy mainstream R&B melodic soap opera couldn't be more far apart. Yet, whether or not R. Kelly intended, his 2005 Trapped in the Closet mimics many techniques Montano employed back in 1977's Mitchell's Death. Rhythm and use of that rhythm in a lengthy format become of use to both Montano and Kelly with respect to their intention. The relationship between Mitchell and Trapped revolutionize such techniques important to endurance, performance, and video art, while simultaneously regarding the development of video itself as a means of communication.

At the time when Mitchell's Death was released, performance art and video art were both already established and developing forms of art that influenced or were influenced by detrimental historical pillars such as the Vietnam war, second wave Feminism, American race riots, and the fast growing media empire found in Hollywood. Born in New York, Linda Montano's artwork mainly focused on the autobiographical performance, where "personal and spiritual discipline" were tested through physical means. "Using performance as a means of personal transformation and catharsis, Mitchell's Death mourns the death of Montano's ex-husband. Every detail of her story, from the telephone call announcing the tragedy, to visiting the body, is chanted by Montano as her face, pierced by acupuncture needles, slowly comes into focus then goes out again. The chanting is reminiscent of Buddhist texts, while the needles signify the pain that is necessary for healing and understanding."1 In a similar fashion to fellow performance artists Vito Acconci or Tehching Hsieh, Montano's video/performance piece dismisses an overstimulating communication popular in American media in turn for a mediative and much simpler approach: one image (Montano's face), one consistent rhythm, and subtle changes (camera focus in and out). Montano directly references communication through more Zen-like methodology.Through this approach, Montano's piece could thus be categorized as "Endurance Art." What exactly is Endurance Art? Though found to be undefined or loosely described, Endurance Art can concretely be defined as a form of art that "mixes rituals of daily living, forms of resistance, body art and social engagement."2 Mitchell's Death tests not only Montano's endurance as she meditatively chants her distressed story for twenty-two straight minutes, but tests the viewer's endurance as they engage with the lengthy material.

Fast forward almost thirty years later, after the start of the new millennia, where "Endurance Art" has seemingly become harder and harder to come by. Television, films, video game, and the ever growing American household ownership of portable gadgets such as the I Pod, I phone, and laptop computer influence art making and the functionality of art in the 21st Century. Though above all media, the Internet as a source of information, entertainment, and leisurely activity changes the atmosphere in totality from the context Linda Montano and other performance artists of the '70's and '80's created their art in. The Youtube.com culture of today simply clicks, fast-forwards, and moves on to the next video with quick ease, as content directed towards today's 21st Century American culture usually rely on vivid overstimulating imagery to catch such a short attention span. Through the Internet, the physical becomes manifested through an alternative reality space, creating a thin line between action and physicality. For instance, Youtube.com replaces user's physical ownership of diary--transforming the act of writing or expressing opinion to downloading their personalized "video diary," or how popular Internet creation "Second Life" allows users to socialize and interact in the alternate reality of the virtual program, and such video game consoles as Wii let users dance, workout, and exist on screen through a series of censors that transmit the user's motion to the screen. In conclusion, the very notion of time, pain, and physicality expressed in Montano and other '70's performance artist's work means multiple things in today's context. It is within this Internet-based generational context that R. Kelly released his Trapped in the Closet.





Originally released as a segment intended to be played on a radio broadcast, the first five chapters of Trapped in the Closet soon grew not only in number throughout 2005 to 2007, but from radio format to video format not long after its creation. In each chapter, Kelly describes his perspective in amultilayered plot featuring relationship conflict, deceit, and death. Kelly represents himself in the video as "Sylvester," but is seen visually as a separate entity from the cast of characters, singing his monologue directly to the camera. New York Times writer Kelefa Sanneh explains the complexity of Kelly's involvement further: "In the beginning 'Trapped' was rooted in the first-person narration of Mr. Kelly as Sylvester: '7 o'clock in the morning, and rays from the sun wake me.' By Chapter 8 Mr Kelly had acquired a second role as the cigar-smoking narrator, broadening the story's scope (we could see things Sylvester didn't) but slightly undermining its intensity. And by Chapter 10 Sylvester's speech had gone third person: 'Sylvester said,' instead of 'I said.' That was when the plot got more farcical; instead of inhabiting Sylvester, Mr. Kelly was toying with him or making him a bystander."3 As Montano recalled her ex-husband's death through a very real personalized perspective, Kelly, too relays his information in a personalized perspective, yet distanced by the fact it is fiction. Both artists involvement are interwoven into the story as the words are interwoven in a continuous rhythmic loop.

Twenty-two times the audience hears the same exact rhythm, stretched to fill an average 4 minute span. In response to the redundancy, critic Pete Blackwell writes: "Simply put, Trapped in the Closet is the worst thing I've ever heard or seen. Unlike other attempts at rock 'opera' (think Tommy, The Wall or even Queen's 'Bohemian Rhapsody'), all five chapters have exactly the same melody."4 Another critic, Tom Breihan of Village Voice, echoes Blackwell's sentiments "The problem with the new 'Trapped' chapters is that Kelly is basically doing the same thing, taking an initially funny and weird and exciting concept and running it into the ground, over and over and over and over."5 It is within this "over and over and over" methodology that Trapped reflects characteristics of an endurance piece. Kelly asks viewers to sit and watch his video as the rhythm continues over and over, over the course of twenty-two chapters. Even if the viewer were to watch each chapter with time in between each viewing, the repetitive nature continues. In a description that cries out Trapped in the Closet, an anonymous writer for Canadian magazine International Contemporary Art reviews endurance art of the 70's:
Much 70s conceptual art (especially time-based work like video and performance) has often struck me as a relatively explicit (if ineffectual) form of meditation instruction. It's so intensely boring that it forces the viewer inward, into a dialogue with his or her interiority. It's different from meditation, of course, in that it simultaneously forces the viewer into dialogue with the artist...There's a structure of domination inherent in every authored work, and that structure is pushed to the fore in the time-based "endurance" works of the 70s. In those cases the author isn't asking the viewer to be entertained or informed by the work, [they're] asking [them] to be annoyed by it. 6
Perhaps R. Kelly didn't intend to annoy the viewers with the redundancy of the rhythm or the overly dramatic soap operatic characteristics, but Kelly does in return question the very medium he uses. Even for a mainstream R&B artist, to question and push the limits of the medium remains risky, perpetuating Kelly's notion as an artist than merely a media mogul. No, Kelly does not physically endure resistance in his daily living, but he does the audience to endure something they wouldn't normally endure in their daily living. Asking that commitment from an audience of today's attention span seems to be the answer to 21st century endurance art.

The cable network "Independent Film Channel" (aka IFC) features uncut and uncensored Independent documentaries, docudramas, short films, and feature length films within a programming lineup intended to bring light to lesser known artists and filmmakers, many previously shown in festival formatting. In August 2007, the IFC began running Trapped in the Closet through their Internet website, spreading Kelly's creation toward a less mainstream audience. Though, even at the popularity peak of Trapped's existence, many audience members and critics alike questioned Kelly's lengthy soap operatic narration. Senneh of New York Times continues; "Some “Trapped” fans may think they’re flattering Mr. Kelly by praising his alleged insanity or naïveté, but that’s the kind of praise that can easily sound like condescension, especially when directed (as it often is) at African-American performers. And some IFC viewers might not know that Mr. Kelly is deploying some of the same dramatic devices you can find in the world of urban theater."3 Senneh brings up a good point--Kelly does borrow and reuse devices in the same way Montano borrowed devices from Buddhist chanting and meditative practices. First, Kelly's Trapped borrowed the communication (language, symbology) from two worlds: Soap Operas and R&B music. And second, Kelly created a monologue that critiqued both redundancy and content in those worlds as viewers were asked to endure nearly ninety minutes of chapter over chapter over chapter.

Labeling Kelly's Trapped in the Closet as art, much less endurance art would categorize it in the same field as Linda Montano's Mitchell's Death. But i'm okay with that. Critic Bill Lamb concludes: "Aside from the controversy and attention, is "Trapped In the Closet" art? Despite his sordid history and current indictment on child pornography charges, R. Kelly is clearly among the most gifted songwriters and performers currently recording. It's nearly impossible to avoid being pulled into the story with a carefully constructed cliffhanger at the end of each chapter. Like some of the best soap operas, "Trapped In the
Closet" also provokes laughter at the near absurdity of the tangled web portrayed. Finally, the issues touched on by the 5-part suite are serious indeed and the drama is likely to provoke needed discussion. Despite any personal opinions about R. Kelly, it must be conceded that "Trapped In the Closet" is likely to stand as a popular music landmark."7 In conclusion, I can safely assume that R. Kelly is not as groundbreaking in the art world as Andy Warhol or Vito Acconci, and that the absurdity that transmits from Trapped may not come across as seriously as the performance of Mitchell's Death, but I firmly believe that Kelly's creation of Trapped borrowed tools that forefronts of performance/endurance/video art such as Linda Montano set during the late seventies. It is with those very tools that endurance art lives on (and on and on...) through developmental changes in technology and communication.












1 Video DateBase http://www.vdb.org/smackn.acgi$tapedetail?MITCHELLSD
2 Diamond, Sara. Endurance, Performance, Surveillance, and Creative Collaboration. University of the Arts London. Sept 2007. http://www.codezebraosphd.com/SDMPhil.UAL.FINAL.pdf
3 Sanneh, Kelefa. Outrageous Farce From R. Kelly: He’s In on the Joke, Right? The New York Times Aug 20, 2007. http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/20/arts/music/20trap.html
4 Blackwell, Pete. Review: R. Kelly Trapped in the Closet. Blogcritics Music. http://blogcritics.org/music/article/review-r-kelly-trapped-in-the/
5 Breihan, Tom, Trapped in the Closet: Ironic or Not? The Village Voice. Aug 22, 2007 http://blogs.villagevoice.com/statusainthood/2007/08/trapped_in_the.php
6 International Contemporary Art. "Two Types of Sacred: 1970s Endurance Art Today" http://goliath.ecnext.com/coms2/gi_0199-4652930/Two-types-of-sacred-1970s.html
7 Lamb, Bill. Trapped in the Closet. About.com Guide. http://top40.about.com/od/trivia/a/trappedcloset.htm
Trapped in the Closet streaming video available at:
Kelly, Robert. "Trapped in the Closet." Independent Film Channel. 2005-2007 http://www.ifc.com/trapped/ http://www.ifc.com/videos/chapter-1.php?video_playlist=1-22